With last night’s loss, the Padres dropped to 3-6 in one-run games this season. One run games are not decided entirely by luck, but luck factors in more to one-run games than to games decided by more runs. This sounds obvious and that’s because it is. One-run games are more likely to hinge on one play, one pitch, one whatever and as such luck plays into it more than in a blowout.
The presumption going into this season is that the Padres are an above average, or at the very least an average team, so it is reasonable to expect a .500 or better record in the close games. Accepting that premise, then, one can see that a 3-6 record in one-run games is likely due to bad luck. Had the Padres won two of the six contests they dropped by one run, they’d be sitting at 11-12 right now and I very much doubt Padre fans would be doing the Chicken Little impressions they are currently.
That topic is tiresome, so I thought I’d address another topic I’ve heard several fans bring up that I personally find more interesting: batting order. We’ll begin with the starting lineup:
C Josh Bard
1B Adrian Gonzalez
2B Tadahito Iguchi
3B Kevin Kouzmanoff
SS Khalil Greene
LF Paul McAnulty
CF Jim Edmonds
RF Brian Giles
Now, first according to The Book, we must identify our three best hitters. Since this is not a terribly serious exercise, we’ll use this year’s numbers to determine that. They are in order: Adrian Gonzalez, Paul McAnulty and Brian Giles. The three best hitters ought to occupy the three most important spots in the lineup: 1st, 2nd and 4th. Gonzalez is the clear choice for 4th because of his power. Giles and McAnulty are getting on base at the same clip, so McAnulty takes the second spot by virtue of having flashed more power.
Next, we look to fill the third and fifth spots in the lineup with our next best remaining hitters. Those hitters are Josh Bard and Kevin Kouzmanoff. They have similar production, but Bard’s is based more in on-base percentage and Kouzmanoff’s in slugging, so it makes sense to slot them third and fifth respectively.
From there, we just order them in descending order of productivity sixth through eighth with the pitcher batting ninth. That gives us for our lineup
RF Brian Giles
LF Paul McAnulty
C Josh Bard
1B Adrian Gonzalez
3B Kevin Kouzmanoff
2B Tadahito Iguchi
SS Khalil Greene
CF Jim Edmonds
Khalil Greene and Jim Edmonds are similar in ability (well, results this year), so there’s an argument to be made for putting Edmonds ahead of Greene o break up the right-handed bats. The offense has been anemic this year, so it couldn’t hurt to try to squeeze out every last run by fielding a more efficient batting order.